As part of a series of posts about new non-fiction books, I am adding reviews about three new titles which deal with Technology.
Hartley uses the subtitle “Why the Liberal Arts Will Rule
the Digital World” to advocate for increasing the human factor and adding more
ethics into our technical tools. There’s
even a chapter titled Building a Better World. I focused, though, on the one
about education where Hartley references works like Moonshots in Education
by Palo Alto High School teacher Esther Wojcicki. Both of these authors explain that
blended learning “fosters creative confidence and complex problem solving in
students. The learning-by-doing
philosophy allows students not only to struggle with projects, but also to
fail, teaching that such failures are inevitable and that perseverance is vital
to success.” This is a key issue that
many of our faculty grappled with at a recent two-day workshop on critical
thinking with Gerald Nosich. We even
talked about a favorite quote from Seth Godin: “Being wrong until you are right: Are there any other options for people who
seek to innovate?”
Full disclosure: I am not a Facebook user though I do worry
about how it causes social disruption in terms of online bullying and the
propagation of fake news and violent videos. [Related article: New York Times (4/25/17) "Can Facebook Fix its Own Worse Bug?"] Hoefflinger (who served as
Facebook’s Lead, Global Business Marketing) argues that “free-to-use
Internet-based services like … Facebook, cannot afford to act with anything but
wild abandon.” Does that seem
irresponsible and worrisome? Perhaps, especially as he says a few pages later
that Facebook has “closely held onto the assets that are core
(information about people and their connections).” So what might happen to that
data? Are not some of the recently raised issues about content and privacy the
result of Facebook needing to come of age as a corporate citizen? Offering an
insider’s perspective, BECOMING FACEBOOK is an interesting and
thoughtful analysis, although it seems a little thin on research and supporting
documentation from outside sources.
PLUGGED IN, on the other hand, was written by two
university professors, Patti M. Valkenburg and Jessica Taylor Piotrowski, and explores
“How Media Attract and Affect Youth.” It is definitely an academic work,
published by Yale University Press and with close to 15% of the text involving
footnotes and sources. This text addresses
some very important topics such as media and violence, advertising, and gaming
across several age ranges. For example,
in the chapter on media and education, the authors acknowledge that the
potential for educational platforms other than television is still being
understood. They cite numerous studies about the ever younger ages at which
children are accessing screens and note findings like “whereas two- to four-year-olds
spend slightly more than an hour a day using educational media, eight- to
ten-year-olds are estimated to spend only forty-two minutes a day with such
content.”
They describe our present day networked society as revolving
around the individual, conjuring an image of “a contemporary family sitting in
a restaurant, parents and children glued to their own phones, unaware of one
another” which complements Turkle’s work in Reclaiming
Conversation. Overall, I think PLUGGED IN addresses a
high interest topic for our students, but its valuable insights are masked by a
very academic tone.
The next set of non-fiction reviews will center on books dealing
with economic opportunity.