It is not often that I read a book in one sitting, but I did
just that with 5 to 1 by Holly Bodger. Set in a dystopian future, this story takes
place over three days of tests where young men vie to be chosen by privileged
women. In this society, it is the male
children who are unwanted and expendable, daughters are valued and pampered. Sudasa,
accompanied by her parents, her sister and her grandmother, has the challenge
of narrowing the field. She must choose
from several, including an obviously well-off boy, one who is crippled, one who
is rather young and a farmer’s son named Kiran, but called 5 for the contest.
5 to 1 is told from alternating points of view:
Sudasa's in verse and 5’s (Kiran's) in prose. This potentially leads to an exploration
of misunderstandings and stereotypes while certainly adding to the tension and
suspense of the fast moving story. This title could work as an assigned read
for literature circles. The poetry is cleverly presented; plus, color and
symbolism are used throughout. In addition, there is much exploration of themes
like obedience/rebellion and self-restraint.
5 to 1 will appeal to strong readers in late middle school and reluctant readers throughout high school. It is a strong debut. We need a sequel.
Note: a slow to load pdf with discussion questions and an educator's guide is located HERE.
